Write About Now

vegging out




It was inevitable, I suppose, that I would become a vegetarian.

For one thing, I don’t like meat all that much–except for In-N-Out burgers.

And in the back of my mind I knew some of the (literally) sickening truths about our modern food industry.

I also knew that if I read Kurlanksy’s book (about regional food traditions before megamarkets and mass production), read Schlosser’s book (about the huge impact the fast food industry has had on our landscape, our socioeconomics, and our health) and watched the movie Food, Inc., that would be it.


So I procrastinated.

Because I like cheeseburgers, even if they are full of fillers washed with ammonia to remove E. coli. I like chicken tacos, even if the slaughter process includes scalding the animals in de-feathering tanks while they’re still alive and aware.


But I finally took the plunge, for a few reasons:

(unless otherwise noted, my sources are the above mentioned books/movies or goveg.com).

Health: My stomach has been jacked up by genetics and stress for years, and I feel much better when I eat a plant-based diet. Not eating meat also makes it easier to control fat and cholesterol and get more vitamins from my calories.

The planet: Although raising grass-fed beef can actually help the environment, 99% of the cows in this country are crammed full of corn and crammed into feedlots instead. This means grassland and forests are being transformed into industrial sprawl, we’re using tons of gasoline and pesticides to guarantee enough corn in enough places, and the process is creating more greenhouse-gas emissions than cars, boats, planes and trains combined. (Check my facts here.) The problem includes poultry and pig farming, as well; According to the Environmental Defense Fund, if every American skipped one meal of chicken per week and substituted vegetarian foods instead, the carbon dioxide savings would be the same as taking more than a half-million cars off U.S. roads (more here).

The animals: According to Food, Inc., in some states farmers want to make it illegal to publish photos of the feedlots. That’s probably not because the areas are humane and clean.

Sometimes the cows are still conscious while they are skinned and torn apart. Both chickens and cows are fed too much and given growth hormones until their legs collapse under their weight or their hearts give out. Pigs receive no painkillers before their tails are chopped off. Chickens spend their entire lives in dark, windowless sheds, sometimes packed so closely they can’t move or lie down. Turkeys’ beaks and toes are burned off with hot blades.

These animals are neglected, kicked, maimed, hung upside down, deprived of sunlight, transported long distances in freezing temperatures and given third-degree burns with branding irons. Treating a dog or cat this way would be illegal.

The grossness: Even if you don’t care about the animals’ quality of life, consider how factory farming affects yours.

“A government health official, who prefers not to be named, compared the sanitary conditions in a modern feedlot to those in a crowded European city during the Middle Ages,” writes Eric Schlosser in Fast Food Nation, “when people dumped their chamber pots out the window, raw sewage ran in the streets, and epidemics raged.” Not only do we leave cattle standing in their own waste, it’s caked to their hides when they go to the slaughterhouses…..and it doesn’t all fall to the floor or get washed off before the meat is ground into burgers.

The FDA currently allows farmers to feed dead chickens and chicken manure to the cows. And to feed dead cows to the chickens.

And according to the USDA, 98% of chicken carcasses are contaminated with E. coli when they reach the grocery store because of the filthy conditions in the sheds where they were raised.

There’s even an argument for vegetarianism in the Bible; although we are certainly told to be fruitful and rule over the earth, including its animals, I find it interesting that there is no mention of Adam and Eve eating meat. God allowed them to eat from any tree in the garden, but only after the flood did he permit eating animals.


So those are my reasons. Now, here are my other decisions:

I won’t be obnoxious about it, compelled to tell everyone disgusting facts about their food. Beyond this blog post, I won’t be one of those people who draws attention to her decision or pontificates on the subject unless invited to share my opinion.

I won’t be unkind. Unless directly asked, I won’t mention it to any hostess who serves meat. (I may even eat it if I decide graciousness trumps conviction in that occasion.) Human feelings are more important than an animal’s.

I will not become a vegan, although that’s the truly intellectually honest thing to do; if I really cared about animal suffering I would give up milk, cheese, and eggs, too—but I like ice cream and cheese pizza and omelets too much. Besides, have you ever tasted seitan? I have, and it makes me gag.

I won’t be judgmental. Some people truly don’t care what’s in their food or how it got there. Others—many, I suspect—know the details are potentially disturbing and choose not to explore further because they like meat and it’s inconvenient to stop eating it. And a few believe it’s liberal and un-Christian to care about animal welfare. (You can have this cheeseburger when you pry it from my cold, dead hands.)

Other than that last snarky comment, I won’t judge those who haven’t made this choice.


Obviously it’s not an issue of salvation. But some of these animals are smarter than dogs and even small children. God (eventually) gave them to us for food, but does that give us license to treat them inhumanely before they’re killed? Mama cows cry for their babies for days after the calves are taken from them and sent to veal farms—does God care, and should we? Yes, humans are to rule over the animals, but does it matter how? And what about stewardship of our bodies?  What do you think?

March 16, 2010 - Posted by | opinions, resources | , , , , , , , , , ,

17 Comments »

  1. Some of my best friends are vegetarians – not that there is anything wrong with that. (I hope you have also made the decision to have a sense of humor about this.)

    Comment by Matt | March 16, 2010 | Reply

  2. I have had the same feelings. I haven’t watched Food Inc yet–not sure I can. I am not planning on beoming a vegetarian but I have done some research on getting a cleaner and better supply of meat for my family. Of course to get grass fed beef and chickens/eggs that are raised humanely costs about 3 times more than conventional products. I have found a great website called eatwild.com to help in my endevor. Next time I have you over, I’ll lay on the veggies!

    Comment by Shannon | March 16, 2010 | Reply

  3. I get what you’re saying. What always kills me is the people (not you, but just in general) who won’t pay $3.50 for organic eggs but will pay $4.59 for Doritos! I’ll check out eatwild.com.

    Comment by Jennifer | March 16, 2010 | Reply

  4. best wishes with grease filled cheesey rally’s big buford in hand

    Comment by anthony florence | March 16, 2010 | Reply

  5. ps good info and discussion no disrespect intended w that silly comment :) look forward to continue reading people’s responses to very interesting topic

    Comment by anthony florence | March 16, 2010 | Reply

    • Best wishes with the heart attack and indigestion :)

      Comment by Jennifer | March 16, 2010 | Reply

  6. you wont miss the cheeseburgers at in n’ out once you try the grilled cheese. so good!

    Comment by kelly | March 16, 2010 | Reply

  7. Oh Jen! I have eaten less and less meat the past couple of years, both for health reasons and for all the reasons you mention in this so brave and articulate post. Morally, I don’t have a problem with eating meat per se but with how the animals I might eat were treated and what the health risks are (two mostly separate issues). Some years back I read an article about how Thanksgiving turkeys are slaughtered, and that was enough for me. I haven’t been brave enough to acquire more horrible facts, but I’m thankful for your roundup here.

    I’ve been buying what little meat we do eat at Whole Foods (where it’s supposed to be certified humane) or Amish or organic brands. Organic milk and organic, free range (that’s important) eggs. Organic cheese has been harder to find nearby.

    Proverbs 12:10 says, “The godly care for their animals, but the wicked are always cruel.” Which side do we want to be on?

    Comment by Diane | March 16, 2010 | Reply

    • I agree; I don’t see a problem with eating meat the way our ancestors did (raise on a farm, treat humanely, eat as needed) but with the industrialization of it and all the related issues that go with that. Love the Proverbs verse.

      Comment by Jennifer | March 17, 2010 | Reply

  8. I am with you sister. I had a really hard time with Food,Inc., then I read Skinny Bitch, then I read Slaughter House…and that was it. Can’t do it any longer. Although, I still have fish every now and again. Play me a movie about the harming of fish and I could be swayed but for some reason the fish seem okay to me for now.
    So, being that we’re on this same page, let’s recipe share! I’ll send some out to you this week!
    And makes me want to watch Notting Hill and crack up at the date set up with the Fruititarian…I love her!
    Hugs!

    Comment by Christie | March 17, 2010 | Reply

    • The one topic we *didn’t* talk about on Saturday. :) Glad to know we are kindred spirits in this way as well!

      Comment by Jennifer | March 17, 2010 | Reply

  9. i’m kind of on the same path. by the end of the summer i’ll have a chicken coop out back where i can control the production of eggs for my family. eventually i’ll eat the meat, but it’ll take me a while to warm up to the idea of killing and eating my own chickens. plus, my kids might not like it too much. “daddy, where’d my pet hen go?” might not be great words to hear depending on my answer :)

    we are also starting a food garden in our back yard and kristy is likely joining a farm co-op in our area that we learned of recently. that will be a big step in our quest to control our food sources.

    i was vegetarian for a while right after high school and ended up with some health issues that were quickly reversed after abandoning that lifestyle. just like anything, there is a right way and a wrong way to go about it. i’m sure you’ll do your research and go about things the right way.

    Comment by adam black | March 17, 2010 | Reply

    • I’m spending some time this weekend planning my garden! This was part of the plan, anyway, but I’m extra excited about it now.

      Comment by Jennifer | March 17, 2010 | Reply

  10. How do you reconcile the gore and brutality of Old Testament animal sacrifice with God’s love? What do you think about fishing and hunting?

    Comment by Robert Carswell | March 17, 2010 | Reply

  11. I don’t see anywhere in the OT where the animals for sacrifice were mistreated or tortured before they were killed for the sacrifice. Again, it’s the inhumane treatment I protest, not the killing itself, which seemed to be quick and without suffering for the animals.

    Hunting and fishing–I get the overpopulation thing, and if people are skillful and use what they eat for food, I’m less annoyed by it. Whole different story if they’re shooting for sport and REALLY whole different story if they don’t finish the job and leave the deer (or whatever) wounded and bleeding.

    Comment by Jennifer | March 17, 2010 | Reply

  12. [...] the cat has gone to the great mouse hunting grounds in the sky, I’ve stopped with the meat completely, and I purchased (terrible, covers-nothing) health insurance. I still sponsor Eko [...]

    Pingback by new to you friday–on the money « Write About Now | August 20, 2010 | Reply


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

Gravatar
WordPress.com Logo

Please log in to WordPress.com to post a comment to your blog.

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.